Your Catholic Match probably sucks.
None of the girls are nearby. Or if they are - they're not attractive at all.
You're probably asking yourself - why do they suck so much? Why can't I get any good quality likes?
The truth is - if you're like the normal guy, you created your profile with 5-6 shitty photos you grabbed from 1-2yr ago in your camera roll.
There's so much competition on these apps nowadays.
You can't get away with old photos. You need a dedicated photo shoot with friends, family, or a pro to get photos specifically meant for dating apps.
Don't be lazy. Get better photos.
And just know - Catholic Match isn't broken. You're just not using it right.